- Joined
- Aug 1, 2015
I'd 100 percent endorse this idea (and it makes perfect sense even within the original trilogy itself) but within AvED it's hard for me to agree with, mostly because they re-wrote Ash from being somewhat shy and bookish and romantic by virtue by turning him into a drunken teenage hellraiser in season 2 to explain Chet. The implication was that he's always been like this and it's a reaction to his father's autocratic parenting.
Eh, i'm gonna have to disagree with this.
Ash was originally supposed to stay dead in the original film alongside with the rest of the characters according to the original creators (sam,rob and bruce), but had to bring him back for the sequel and retconned some of his character traits and backstory from that film plus the other characters from ed1. it doesn't help either that they've had to pull the ole "unreliable narrator/retcon" to explain the continuity error's with ash's backstory and it's snowballed into well the gag we know now.
Ash's character and his characterization as a whole has been a jumbled up mess in general from the original series due to this running gag and the legal issues so they could go anywhere with it, so stepping into AvED with this established main character and now having the options now to use the characters from ed1,2 and AoD some what (The ed2 ending loophole). Which version of ash were they gonna play on and add on to that the fans remember the most ?
The AoD ash naturally because that version had the most characterization and the most memorable dialogue out of the two previous iteration's, so they are gonna expand on that version the most and they could pull off the burnt out mid life crisis angle better with that version. (And they have mentioned this is what they envisioned ash being like after AoD)
So, how do you expand upon AoD ash when you don't have the rights to said film he was promptly in and only have the first two films to go off of for this series ?
UNRELIABLE NARRATOR/RETCON. (the 2 unholy demon's of this franchise)
The problem with ash's current persona really isn't with the lazy writing, it's the current/previous writers/original creators getting backed into a corner of trying to expand on a character that hasn't really had a cohesive/straight forward expanded backstory in a trilogy of films that have been all over the place with how it's laid out it's timeline and it's main character's persona over the course of 3 films. Naturally they have went their own route with it. They have nailed some elements of it and faltered in some.
it's at this point I've stopped caring about how ash is portrayed to fit with the films previously because it's a unrealistic expectation at this point and to put it bluntly, those previous iterations of ash are in the past and buried and those 3 films did have one cohesive complete character arc for ash and that's the nerd>semi-badass>full on badass arc he had with some side love interest's for him to care about and that's about it. So where the hell do they go from there when ash's arc was already completed in AoD ? The only real thing ash has left for a long arc is his prophecy.
Ash as a character at this point, needs a conclusive ending and i get the strangest feeling we "might" see that this season plus some solid character work underneath the jokes and crudeness his character is currently shackled with.
*end rambling*
