Saw the movie tonight. Not sure what to make of it yet. Full disclosure: I went to dinner right by the theater before the movie and had a few drinks. I'm certain that made me have more fun, but I had a good time. Not a perfect movie, of course, but I go into these new movies with my brain turned off and expecting nothing close to the original trilogy. Maybe I just look for the positives because it's Evil Dead? No spoilers below
I have to hand it to Sebastien for trying some new stuff, even if it didn't all work. There were some really cool scenes with good camera work that reminded me a lot of the old movies, and the ending reminded me of one of the maps in Evil Dead: The Game. His Deadites are definitely different, but it kind of makes sense given how they came about? However, none of them really stuck out to me except for one. It was definitely a brutal film, although I didn't find it any more gruesome or extreme than anything else in the franchise. I also found some of the scenes rather hilarious in an understated way, similar to the humor in Rise.
That being said, some of the kills were recycled and stale, and I didn't care all that much for Alice. Her being French gave her a certain sort of flair, but these final girls get less memorable with each film. Mia is still the one, if they were to tie it all together, that I'd like to see brought back for another movie. The color of the movie also made it feel like one long scene that was difficult to break into individual sections. Thinking back now, it's not easy to remember what happened where.
It was worth a watch. Nothing groundbreaking, nothing new, but there are definitely way worse entries in nearly every other major horror franchise. As a fan of many of those franchises, I can appreciate that the worst Evil Dead movie is much better than the worst F13, Halloween, or TCM movie. It also has me intrigued and excited about Wrath, more than anything. I could see Burn being the sort of black sheep entry in the franchise (that will still have its fans), while Wrath is the payoff they've been building toward since 2013 or Rise. It's clear that Raimi/Tapert/Campbell have something in mind, whatever that is. Whatever the case, Wrath has my attention, and I would be thrilled if they can somehow hit a homerun with that one.
tl;dr: Burn had some really cool aspects and some not so cool aspects, tried some new stuff to mixed results.
My ranking is as follows:
Evil Dead 2
Army of Darkness
The Evil Dead
AvED
Evil Dead 2013
Evil Dead Burn
Evil Dead Rise